The Importance of Reverifying a Criminal Record Check on Employees

Tim Hardie • Feb 08, 2024

Conducting a criminal record check is often carried out when a new employee is brought onto the team. However, reverifying these checks throughout an individual's employment is often necessary to keep your workforce safe, stay compliant, and maintain accurate employee records.


Reverification is simply the act of running any type of background check throughout the employee's time working for the company. This process is similar to the initial employee screening and provides several benefits for your organization.


Read on to learn more about why carrying out a new Canadian criminal record check after an employee is hired is well worth the time and resources.


What Do You Look for When Reverifying a Criminal Record Check?


Reverifying any type of background check is usually done to look for specific information or validate existing information. So, what should your business look for when carrying out a new record check?


The answer will vary for every business and every role within it. For example, someone who works with the elderly, as well as children and youth or other vulnerable populations, will need periodic vulnerable sector police checks. This is to ensure no new areas of concern have been identified and that the past check was accurate.


Criminal record checks focus on law enforcement actions, making them widely applicable to different roles and organizations. Before you run a new check, make sure you understand what information specifically you’re seeking out. This extra step ensures you’re running the correct type of background check.


The Importance of Periodic Reverification


Many organizations consider the initial background check sufficient to screen employees and identify any areas of concern. However, it’s crucial to periodically conduct reverification checks to ensure no new charges or other areas of concern have occurred since being hired on.


Additionally, scheduled periodic reverification may also need to be supplemented by other events, such as promotions or role changes, which we’ll explore more later on.


Risk Mitigation


Every business faces risks and these risks only grow alongside your organization’s growth. Conducting a new criminal record check in Canada helps mitigate some of these risks by identifying any discrepancies, new issues, or other concerns throughout the workforce. 


As a result, periodic reverification contributes to reducing legal and reputational risks. You’ll be able to identify and correct any possible issues before they may cause serious problems for customers, clients, or other employees.


Compliance


New regulator requirements are emerging seemingly every day, while existing compliance requirements continually evolve over time. Depending on your industry, you may be required to conduct periodic criminal background checks. Alternatively, a new regulation may require them in the future.


It’s crucial to understand any regulations regarding employee records or reverification frequency. Failing to comply can result in a range of negative consequences depending on your industry.


Keeps Records Accurate


Even if it's not required by any regulations, making sure your employee records are up to date is highly valuable for any business. HR, managers, and C-suite will have confidence in the workforce by making sure the initial check is accurate and any new issues have been identified.


We’re focusing on criminal background checks, but it’s essential to be aware there are other types of checks you might want to reverify over time. You may even be required to reverify them based on your industry. Some standard reverifying checks include:


  • Criminal background check: This is arguably the most common check we see businesses conducting during reverification checks. A Canada criminal record check includes a range of subcategories depending on your specific needs, most of which contain checking the employee with local and federal law enforcement.
  • Employment eligibility: These checks simply verify that the individual is eligible to work in Canada. You may need to reverify these in specific situations or to make sure the initial check was accurate. This type of check also applies to any immigrants or migrant workers.
  • Credit history check: Some industries require credit history checks, such as financial businesses or those that work with sensitive data. Credit scores generally change over time, so they’re worth reverifying periodically if necessary to your industry and compliance standing.
  • License and certification verification: Any type of credential may need to be reverified periodically as many expire or lose validity. Be aware that this applies to any employees throughout the organization to stay on top of applicable licensing and certification.

When Should You Reverify?


How often should you conduct reverifying checks? The answer will vary based on your industry and business practices, but we can still go over a few general guidelines.


Events That May Trigger Reverifying


Some events occurring naturally throughout an employee's time working for your company may trigger the need to reverify. Common events that might call for reverifying include:


  • Role changes: A significant promotion or lateral movement might call for reverification or even a different type of background check that has not been conducted. For example, an employee may move into a higher-risk position with more access to sensitive data, necessitating reverifying criminal history or a credit check.
  • Work authorization expiration: While not every employee has specific work authorizations, others will. Document the expiration date when these employees are hired and conduct re-verification when the expiration date is reached. 
  • Reported major life events: Depending on your organization, it may be necessary to conduct new background checks if an employee reports a life change. Such changes include bankruptcies, legal name changes, or even divorces. However, you need to be aware of any applicable privacy laws when reverifying for these reasons.


You may have unique events depending on your business and industry, so be aware of any other possible events not included in the above list.


Regularly Scheduled Reverification


Creating a schedule for reverification is advised for most businesses. Some employers may not have an event that triggers reverification, so having a premade schedule helps ensure everyone is up to date.


So, how often should you reverify? Many organizations conduct annual reverification, while others may conduct them every two or three years. The right choice for your business depends on any regulations, type of industry, or best practices. Make the decision now and stick to ensure your records are accurate.


Legal or Compliance Requirements


Some regulations may call for reverification checks to remain compliant. Research any regulations or compliance certifications related to your business that require frequently updated criminal checks or other types of background checks.


It’s common for third parties to conduct audits to ensure you’re meeting all standards and expectations. Recent criminal record checks may be part of these audits, so make sure they’re conducted as required and the results are appropriately stored.


Additionally, employers need to stay aware of any changes in regulatory requirements that may necessitate reverifying employees. Stay on top of any changes related to compliance standings to avoid potential fines and penalties.


Benefits of Regular Reverification


We’ve touched on some of the benefits of reverification already, but let’s drill down into some more detailed ways this practice can help your organization.


Create a Safer Workplace


Conducting recurring criminal background checks helps identify any potential concerns and take corrective action before they may impact workplace safety. If the initial check missed a violation or a new violation has occurred since employment, the employee may be a risk to customers and employees.


You’ll ensure that you create and foster a positive workplace and show employees you care for their safety by identifying any red flags and taking corrective action when necessary.


Reduce Liability


Employers can safeguard their organization from possible damage caused by a problematic employee who stays under the radar. Recurring background checks help identify any issues that were missed to avoid the possibility of behavior that may create problems for your company. 


Additionally, while this is not legal advice, it’s possible being able to showcase a recent background check may help shield you from liability in specific instances.


Bolster Employer-Employee Trust


Employees need to trust employers to provide a safe and problem-free workplace. Recurring reverification checks are one aspect of keeping everyone at the workplace safe from potential issues.


Additionally, being transparent and open about these checks also promotes your company culture. Making it clear that you’re running new checks and explaining the reasoning goes far in promoting trust among employees.


Streamline Reverifying with Hire Performance Inc.


Reverifying your entire workforce periodically or at specific events might seem like a daunting task, and it might be when using older background check methods. 


Fortunately, Hire Performance Inc. has brought background checks into the future with our streamlined, on-demand web app. Now, you can request, monitor, and finalize background checks from your browser and avoid the lengthy email chains. We've enhanced our service by introducing a 're-check button', allowing you to easily submit a recheck on a previous report. This feature makes it faster to submit a new request on an existing employee without having to fill out their information again, simplifying the process of maintaining up-to-date background checks.


Are you ready to simplify reverifying criminal checks? Team up with Hire Performance Inc. to get a Canadian Criminal Record Check today.

Industry Leading Technology for Background Checks & Screening

eScreener uses Kount Identity Verification™ technology to verify identity with confidence. This technology cross checks applicant information against Equifax and 3rd party data sources to validate an identity and to determine whether that identity has been reported as misused or associated with potential fraudulent activity. This is done in real time by accessing millions of records, providing instant results in our eScreener.

eScreener Demo

WHY CHOOSE HIRE PERFORMANCE?

Pre-Employment Screening Benefits

Our industry leading expertise and cutting edge technology help organizations detect potential risks such as resume fraud, criminal convictions, and past terminations.

Read More Benefits

Business Costs Icon

Business Costs

Reduce hiring mistakes by identifying the most qualified candidates.

Lower Turnover Icon

Lower Turnover

Experience better employee attendance rates and lower turnover.

Avoid Litigation Icon

Avoid Litigation

Identify a candidate that may have a history of violence or theft.

Increase Applicant Quality Icon

Increase Applicant Quality

Find qualified candidates for vacant positions at your organization.

Share by: